Readers | Upstate
Grotto Pizza
various locations, grottopizza.com
Readers | Downstate
Grotto Pizza
various locations, grottopizza.com
Gourmet Pizza | Critics
Pizza by Elizabeths
3801 Kennett Pike, Greenville, 654-4478, pizzabyelizabeths.com
We get a kick out of the clever names like The Montgomery and the Barrett Browning for the house pies, but we really enjoy choosing our own crust, sauce and toppings.