Type to search

Best Restaurants in Sussex County: A restaurant guide for eating out around Bethany Beach


Baja Beach House Grill Mexican
109 Garfield Pkwy., Bethany, 537-9993, bajabeachhouse.com
Faves include taco salad and burritos enchiladas.  $$

Bethany Blues BBQ Pit American
6 N. Pennsylvania Ave., Bethany, 537-1500, bethanyblues.com
Southern barbecue, seafood, steaks and St. Louis-style ribs.  $$ 

Blue Coast Seafood Grill American
111 Highway One, Bethany, 539-7111, bluecoastseafoodgrill.com
Waterfront sunsets and modern cuisine. 50-plus wines.  $$$

The Blue Crab American
210 Garfield Pkwy., Bethany, 537-4700
Family place specializes in crab dishes.  $$$

The Chalkboard Tavern American
116 Marketplace at Sea Colony, Bethany, 539-7482
Fresh seafood, great steaks and a few creative chicken dishes.  $$$

DiFebo’s Restaurant and Deli Italian
789 Garfield Pkwy., Bethany, 539-4550, difebos.com
Truly excellent seafood and pasta and more. Full bar and wine list.  $$   

Grotto Pizza Italian
98 Garfield Pkwy., Bethany, 539-3398; York Beach Mall, Del. 1, Bethany, 537-6600; 793 Garfield Pkwy., Bethany, 537-3278; grottopizza.com
Pizzas use a unique blend of Wisconsin cheeses and California sauce to please.  $$

Mango’s Caribbean
Garfield Parkway at the Boardwalk, Bethany, 537-6621, mangomikes.com
Enjoy West Indies-inspired fare in an island-themed family atmosphere on the boardwalk.  $$

Matt’s Fish Camp Seafood
28635 Coastal Hwy., Bethany, 539-2267, mattsfishcamp.com
Casual, comfortable fish shack-style fare.  $$

McCabe’s Gourmet Market American
Del. 1, York Beach Mall, South Bethany, 539-8550, mccabesgourmet.com
Great salads, breads, croissants, cheeses and meats.  $

Off the Hook American
769 Garfield Pkwy., Bethany, 829-1424, offthehookrestaurantbb.com
Dedicated to local produce and locally caught fish.  $$

The Parkway Restaurant American
114 Garfield Pkwy., Bethany, 537-7500, parkwaydana.com
The New York strip, rack of lamb and crab cakes stand out.  $$$

Patsy’s Restaurant American
121 Campbell Place, Bethany, 537-CHEF, patsysgourmet.com
Key West and Southern-inspired cuisine specializing in fresh seafood, all-natural beef and organic vegetables.  $$$

Sedona American
26 Pennsylvania Ave., Bethany, 539-1200, sedona-bethany.com Try the ahi tuna, duck and mahi dishes.  $$$

Get the Delaware Today Best Restaurants Guide for FREE!

Keep a pulse on local food, art, and entertainment content when you join our Delaware Today newsletter.

No thank you
Delaware best restaurants