Type to search

Best Restaurants in Sussex County: A restaurant guide for eating out around Fenwick Island


Captain Pete’s Mediterranean Cove Greek
700 Coastal Hwy., Fenwick Island, 537-5900
Start with the appetizer for two: dolmades, spanikopita, hummus, meatballs and more. (seasonal)  $$$

Catch 54 Fish House American
Del. 54, Shark’s Cove Marina, Fenwick Island, 436-8600, catch54.com
Delicious seafood, water views. (Re-opening in spring. Call for details.) $$$  

Fenwick Crab House American
100 Coastal Hwy., Fenwick Island, 539-2500, fenwickcrabhouse.com
It may be known for crab cakes, but its barbecued ribs are delicious.  $$

Harpoon Hannah’s American
Del. 54, Fenwick Island, 539-3095, harpoonhannasrestaurant.com
Seafood, steak, ribs and pasta. Frozen drinks go great with burgers and sandwiches.  $$$

Mancini’s Brick Oven Pizzeria and Restaurant Italian
601 Coastal Hwy., Fenwick Island, 537-4224, mancinisbop.com
Authentic Neapolitan pizza. Serves pasta and Italian seafood, too.  $$

Nantuckets Restaurant American
601 Coastal Hwy., Fenwick Island, 539-2607,  nantucketsrestaurant.com
A charming restaurant featuring wonderful foods and fine wines. Serving guests for more than 20 years.  $$$

Smitty McGee’s Raw Bar and Restaurant American
Del. 54, W. Fenwick Island, 436-4716, smittymcgees.com
The menu packs more than 100 items: wings, burgers and chicken.  $$

Warren’s Station American
1406 Coastal Hwy., Fenwick Island, 539-7156, warrensstation.com
Family-style dining inside a replica of a local lifesaving station. The sliced roast turkey, served with all the trimmings, is a specialty.  $$