Pizza by Elizabeths, Grotto, DiMeo’s, Casa DiLeo: Best Pizza in Delaware

Readers, upstate 
Pizza By Elizabeths • 3801 Kennett Pike, Greenville, 654-4478, pizzabyelizabeths.com

Readers, downstate
Grotto Pizza • various locations, grottopizza.com

Editors, upstate
At the new DiMeo’s Pizza, it’s all about pies made with ingredients imported from Italy, but the real proof of its preeminence is the crust—crispy, light, delicious.
831 N. Market St., Wilmington, 655-1427, dimeospizza.com

Editors, downstate
In a town full of great pizza places, Casa DiLeo is as close to real New York-style pizza as you’ll get at the beach. The locals know. 721 Rehoboth Ave., Rehoboth Beach, 226-8660, casa-dileo.com